Beyond Fear and Control: Working with young people who self harm
ISBN 978 1 898 05987 5 (2007)
As the title Beyond Fear and Control suggests, this book aims to move services away from responses based on fear and assumptions that we need to manage and control young people who self harm. It discusses ways in which services can change the focus from managing or 'stopping' self harm to working with young people in more permissive, ‘young person centred’ and empowering ways. Although the need for such a change is increasingly being recognised, the practical implications and ethical dilemmas of this shift have rarely been explored. This book addresses this gap by providing in-depth descriptions of a range of innovative practices which are effective in supporting young people who self harm.
Sam Warner appeared on a Radio 4 Woman's Hour item on self harm on May 24th 2007. To listen to this item click on the link below and select from the menu.
Part One: Working alongside Young People
1. A Dialogue of Hope and Survival. Clare Shaw and Terri Shaw
2. Edges and Ledges: Reflections on informal support at 42nd Street Eamonn Kirk
3. Finding your own Voice: Social Action group work with young people Keith Green
4. Supportive communities and helpful practices: the challenge for services Ian Murray
Part Two: Abuse, Oppression and Self Harm
5. Calming Down: self injury as stress control Rose Cameron
6. Whose Fear Is It Anyway? Working with young people who dissociate Theres Fickl
7. Disordered Boundaries?: A critique of ‘Borderline Personality Disorder’ Gillian Proctor
8. 'To that piece of each of us that refuses to be silent’: Working with self harm and black identity Vera Martins
Part Three: Strategies of Survival
9. Self Injury and the Law: What choices do we really have? Sam Warner and Doug Feery
10. Weaving different practices: Working with children and young people who self-harm in prison Carolyn McQueen
11. Harm-Minimisation: limiting the damage of self-injury Louise Roxanne Pembroke
12. Exercising Choice and Control: Independent Living, Direct Payments and Self Harm Helen Spandler and Pauline Heslop
Beyond Fear and Control has a strong message. Its call for change is not based solely on academic research but also on the day to day work with the young people who self-injure. It is their collective voice which comes through loud and clear. There is a desperate need for change from unhelpful attitudes which are dismissive, paternal, patronising and sometimes punitive to ones which are more accepting, respectful and supportive. In relation to approaches used, the message is to shift the focus away from control and stopping self-harm to the more effective permissive person-centred support which acknowledges the person experiencing the self-harm as the central source of information and learning. In conclusion, I believe this book lives up to its title and delivers what that title suggests, namely, how as a profession and as a society we can move 'beyond fear and control' when 'working with young people who self harm'. As such I would recommend this book to any person who has a desire to learn more about self-injury. I believe it makes a valid addition to the existing literature on self-harm. In BJGC 36(4) 2008, reviewed by Doreen Fleet, Counsellor, Supervisor and Trainer, Keele University.
... it could well be a good introduction for counsellors and psychotherapists who want to learn more about the improtance of empowering young people who self-injure. Jules Martin, director of FirstSigns reviewed in the January 2009 issue of HCPJ.